Idiot Evangelical Christian Filmmaker Claims to Find “Noah’s Ark.” No Conflict of Interest Reported

So, a Hong Kong based film maker has claimed to find Noah’s Ark, ecased in ice on the top of Mount Ararat in Turkey.

This story pisses me off on several levels. First and foremost, the film maker is not a researcher or historian, in fact Yeung Wing-Cheung is a Evangelical Christian film maker whose entire project has been funded by a Christian organization. In other words, this guy isn’t out for history, or science, but like so many before him, to prove that a story in the bible is indicative of an otherwise undocumented historical event.

Yeung has started off this expedition with something to prove, not a hypothesis, or a place of objectivity, which makes any “data” supplied by his team suspect.

To Yeung’s credit, he is asking historians and scientists to verify his claims, but even if the wooden structure he’s “discovered” is a boat, dating from the “correct era” (and who decides what the hell the correct date for Noah’s ark could be?) it still doesn’t prove that it was Noah’s Ark, or that it had anything to do with biblical scripture.

Here’s the gist of the article from ABC News:

Yeung Wing-Cheung of Hong Kong said he is “99 percent” sure the wooden structure he filmed along with Turkish scientists and archeologists is the remnants of the famed ark God instructed Noah to build to save himself and the world’s animals from an epic flood.

“We are not saying that we are 100 percent certain that what we found is Noah’s Ark. No one has ever seen the ark, no one knows what it looks like,” Yeung said. “We are only 99 percent certain that it is Noah’s Ark based on historical accounts, including the Bible and local beliefs of the people in the area, as well as carbon dating.”

It would be a discovery for the ages. But skeptics are already questioning Yeung’s find, especially since he refuses to say exactly where he found the supposed ark with its wooden chambers still intact.

“I’m not quite 99.9 percent sure it’s Noah’s Ark, but they’ve got something,” George Washington University’s Eric Cline told “Good Morning America.” “I’m waiting for them to convince me.”

He suggested it could even be a very old shepherd’s hut.

“I would want to first of all try to figure out their data, verify it,” he said.

Even though the precise location of the latest find has been kept secret, Cline said Yeung and his scientists would need to “parachute in” a large team of independent experts and archaeologists to study the wood and surrounding areas.

“In terms of Noah’s Ark, I would have suspected it would have perished long ago,” he said. “The wood should just have disintegrated.”

Cline said that if Noah’s Ark had come to rest atop a remote mountain, as the Bible suggests, it’s reasonable that he would have dismantled his ship to use the wood for shelter.

“Instead of Noah’s Ark, I would be looking for Noah’s first house or something like that,” he said.

They say the wood has been tested and carbon dates to around the time Noah was afloat. [WTF? Who determines when Noah would have been afloat???]

Mount Ararat has long been the favored theory for the ark’s final resting place. At 2½ miles up, Yeung’s video shows straw lying on the structure’s floor.

“We are sure,” one Turkish scientist said with the help of a translator, “these parts belong to the ship of Noah.”

For centuries, every few years people have claimed to have found Noah’s Ark. In 2006, American Christians claimed to have found a rock formation that resembles the ark very close to Yeung’s site.

“I’m waiting for them to convince me,” Cline said. “But who knows? Stranger things have happened.”

Yeung got involved with the project in 2004. He said he used three cameramen. The research and the trip to Mount Ararat was financed by his Christian organization, but he declined to say how much was shelled out.

Yeung said he plans to go back to the site again, but first will appeal to scientists throughout the world to examine their findings.”

Advertisements

~ by K. Ritcheson on April 29, 2010.

One Response to “Idiot Evangelical Christian Filmmaker Claims to Find “Noah’s Ark.” No Conflict of Interest Reported”

  1. […] In a totally unsurprising turn of events, serious doubt is being cast on the Noah’s Ark Discovery I blogged about last […]

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s

 
%d bloggers like this: